To be or not to be?, Elections elections.., Platforms’ actions.
Disinfo Update 24/06/2019
Time to draw some conclusions, “Secondary Infektion”, Facebook’s Libra
Disinfo Update 17/06/2019
Back from RightsCon
Last week, human rights in the digital era conference RightsCon held it’s 8th edition in Tunis. The EU DisinfoLab had the chance to attend many sessions and to conduct a workshop on building cross-expertise to tackle disinformation. Here are our quick take-aways from RightsCon:
- Disinformation is definitely a very global issue which calls for international regulation. But at the same time, its field impact could only be reduced by empowering local communities;
- Disinformation operates differently in various communities. But, similar patterns are rising: the need to improve trust between stakeholders, to develop helpdesk to alert journalists when campaigns are unfolding, to build resilience within civil society;
- Develop ethical standards for both investigative bodies and facts amplifiers as well as reinforcing clarity of sources of information was also discussed.
This clearly highlights the EU DisinfoLab mission to research and document disinformation cases, help to bridge communities and expertise at a local level while pushing for impactful regulation at the international level.
EU Code of Practice Against Disinformation: “last but not least”
Last Friday, Facebook, Google and Twitter have released their monthly reports on the EU Code of Practice Against Disinformation. It is to note that on 22 May 2019, Microsoft joined the Code of Practice and subscribed to all its commitments. Nevertheless, the trade associations subscribed to the Code, haven’t released their reports since January 2019. In our article you can find the summaries of all the reports of online platforms, as well as the main actions undertaken by the European Commission to tackle disinformation online.
At the same time, European institutions released a joined report on the implementation of the Action Plan Against Disinformation, in the context of the European parliamentary elections. The report does not identify cross-border disinformation campaign from external actors but collected evidence of sustained disinformation activities by Russian sources.
As for the next steps, the assessment by the European Regulators Group for Audiovisual Media Services (ERGA), based on the monthly monitoring reports published by the platforms, will be adopted on 21/06. The Commission underlines that based on this assessment, further actions may be considered to ensure and improve long-term response to the threat.
Library
- Digital marketer Mailchimp bans anti-vaccination content, following the similar actions taken by other tech companies including Facebook and Amazon.
- A fake video of Mark Zuckerberg giving a sinister speech about the power of Facebook has been posted on Instagram. The company previously said it would not remove this type of videos.
- The research piece ‘Democratic Defence Against Disinformation’ published by Alina Polyakova and Daniel Fried from the Atlantic Council analyses the rapid development of policy responses of governments and social media companies to the challenge of disinformation.
- After having been breached, WhatsApp said that the hack could come from “a government using surveillance technology, and it may have targeted human rights groups.”
- Twitter updated its operation information archive with new accounts.
- For TheNextWeb, today’s problem is not the offensive content that people can seek out on Youtube, but the content we don’t seek out. This article has analysed the presentation of Guillaume Chaslot, the Founder of AlgoTransparency, at the EU DisinfoLab Conference.
Calendar and announcements
- 18-21 June @ Cape Town, Africa: Global Fact 6, the International Fact-Checking Network’s annual summit.
- 19-20 June @ UNESCO Headquarters in Paris: 63rd meeting of the International Programme for the Development of Communication.
- 20 June at 16:00 CEST: EU DisinfoLab Webinar with the ISD Global on Propaganda and Digital Campaigning in the EU Elections. Join the event via this link.
- 20-21 June @ London: DFR Lab Digital Sherlocks 360/OS.
- 25 June @ Brussels, European Parliament: #MEDIA4DEMOCRACY: Strategy for media ecosystem 2019-2024, with ‘Democracy Commissioner’ and ‘MEP media intergroup.‘
HR
- Who Targets Me is looking for a Policy Researcher.
- Walt Disney Television is looking for a Social Newsgathering Producer.
- Digital Action is hiring a full-time Project Lead, starting as soon as possible.
Disinfo Update 11/06/2019
You wish to receive this by email? Subscribe here.
A bad week for OSINT
For journalists, fact-checkers and NGO’s using Open-Source information to document disinformation, war crimes and propaganda, last week has just been hell. Just after Michael Bazzell’s website was hacked, forcing the very useful (and free) IntelTechniques tools to be removed (more info here on Michael’s podcast), Facebook also took a decisive step against OSINT community.
By cutting off its Graph search tools, Facebook didn’t leave any possibility for the fact-checkers and journalists to search for public posts around keywords or UID. Meanwhile, Facebook also published a paper last week on preserving privacy while fostering meaningful research on elections and democracy. The company is describing some of the approaches it is taking towards external contributions on this issue.
To look at the first impact on the civil society: Nick Waters from Bellingcat had to launch a call for help on Twitter in order to document air strikes in Yemen. Facebook commented its decision saying they “paused” these features because they want to improve keywords search. This last move from Facebook raises many questions around how civil-society can act as a counter-power to assess accountability of malicious actors on platforms. A topic that will surely be heavily discussed at RightsCon this week in Tunis. Our workshop on building cross-expertise to fight disinformation is scheduled on Thursday 2 PM. Feel free to join.
EU vs Disinformation
A mysterious online campaign targeting leading European Commission presidential candidates Weber and Timmermans was featured on Google and Facebook, despite breaching both companies’ rules on political advertising. In fact, social media channels have witnessed numerous disinformation campaigns targeting the EU candidates. We have collected several reports related to the European parliamentary elections on this resources webpage. Additionally, an analysis of BBC Newsnight has illustrated how disinformation was spread in Facebook groups during the EU elections. The EU Observer has published six takeaways on digital disinformation at EU elections. It is to note that the upcoming EU DisinfoLab Webinar with ISD Global will elaborate on “Propaganda and Digital Campaigning in the EU Elections“. Join us on 20th of June at 16:00 CEST following this link.
Falling in the Deepfake
The development of new technologies and software tools does not seem to be always force for good. Today, with the latest examples of deepfake technology, users can add, delete, or change the words coming right out of somebody’s mouth. Scientists have shown that creating realistic fakes is becoming easier every day by designing a new technique to produce AI deepfakes that only requires entering in the text you want the person to say. The Witness Media Lab has explained the 11 things we can do now to prepare for deepfakes. Dr. Regina Rini, referring to the deepfake video of Nancy Pelosi in an opinion piece for the New York Times says: “You should only trust a recording if you would trust the word of the person producing it.”
Library
- The EU DisinfoLab has published its article on the Media Literacy session of the EU DisinfoLab Annual Conference that took place on 29/09. The session was part of the European project ‘Open Your Eyes‘.
- The publicly available presentations of speakers of the EU DisinfoLab conference and a selection of photos are available here.
- Social media platforms have become overrun with fake news, creating the need for smart AI-based filters to separate fact from fiction.
- Fact-checkers launch Instagram, WhatsApp and Telegram stickers to gently warn about false news.
- The Global Disinformation Index has published its Weekly Reading List.
- Twitter has entirely rewritten its policies on Platform Manipulation and Spam.
- Naturalnews, a far-right conspiracy website promoting vaccine disinformation and mass arrests of the left, was banned by Facebook.
- Nigeria’s “Fake News” Ecosystem: The exponential growth in use and availability of mobile phones with access to the Internet, as well as the sheer amount of information accessible online, has made filtering out false information difficult.
Calendar and announcements
- 11-12 June @ Riga: Riga Stratcom Dialogue 2019.
- 13 June at 2:15pm – 3:30pm @ Tunis: Session on “How to build civil society cross-expertise in response to disinformation” hosted by EU DisinfoLab at RightsCon Summit.
- 19-20 June @ UNESCO Headquarters in Paris: 63rd meeting of the International Programme for the Development of Communication.
- 20-21 June @ London: DFR Lab Digital Sherlocks 360/OS.
- 25 June @ Brussels, European Parliament: #MEDIA4DEMOCRACY: Strategy for media ecosystem 2019-2024, with ‘Democracy Commissioner’ and ‘MEP media intergroup‘.
- KnightFoundation launches its podcast series that examines how museums and cultural institutions are evolving to keep pace with a changing world.
Disinfo Update 27/05/19
First glance at disinformation around the EU elections; Call me maybe?; Are you coming to the EU DisinfoLab Annual Conference?
Disinfo Update 20/05/19
April edition of the EU Code of Practice against disinformation; International call for action on content moderation; Platforms fighting anti-vaccination propaganda.
Disinfo Update 06/05/19
Populist believing on conspiracies; rating disinformation; fact-checking monopoly?
Disinfo Update 29/04/2019
Last week, the major online platforms have published their monthly report on the EU Code of Practice against disinformation.